
Over the Christian centuries there has, more often than not, been a stress on the moral and spiritual choices of individuals, and that has skewed the Parable of the Sheep and the Goats in Matthew 25 toward an individual’s responsibility to engage in what are called works of mercy. This emphasis is important, but it often causes us to overlook the fact that the judgment presented in this parable is a judgment of nations, not a judgment of individuals. This emphasis is all the more apposite when we are celebrating the Feast of Christ the King as a preparation for the season of Advent..
The usual historical trend for kingship is that a consolidation of political, social, and economic power is gained by a few people who take advantage of that power to, in essence, enslave the rest of the populace. pushing most people to the margins. The people at the center count, the people on the margins don’t. In Ephesians, Paul says that “God placed all things under his feet and appointed him to be head over everything for the church, which is his body, the fullness of him who fills everything in every way.” (Eph. 1: 22) This looks like a traditional imperial image of Christ’s kingship, suggesting a ruler who bosses everybody else about. But is it? Paul is writing about a king who was first crucified and then raised from the dead. Doesn’t look like a mafia boss type of king to me. Rather, a person pushed to the margins has been placed at the center of authority, an authority that, in the parable given by Jesus just before his passion and crucifixion, insists that those at the margins count at least as much as those in the center of power, if not a lot more. Quite a reversal of the way kingship normally works.
We have in the Parable of the Sheep and Goats (Mt. 25: 31–45) a clear vision that society should be structured, not around economic and political power, but around the weakest, the most helpless members. Has anybody even tried such a thing? In the face of many regressions toward the traditional ways of power, the Church has, over the centuries, expended much effort towards relieving the miseries of the weaker members of society. A particularly strong focus of this value is enshrined in the Rule of St. Benedict, to the extent that the whole Rule can be read as a commentary on this Parable in Matthew’s Gospel.
Perhaps the strongest impression of Benedict’s application of the Parable comes in the chapter on the receiving of guests. Noting the vulnerability of all guests everywhere, Benedict says that all guests should be received as Christ, in reference to Matthew 25. Moreover, Benedict says that special attention should be devoted to guests who are poor, and to pilgrims, because Christ is especially present in them. That is, the weaker the person, the stronger the presence of Christ. In reference to normal power structures, Benedict notes that the rich and powerful gain respect and deference on their own accord.
Benedict also refers to Matthew 25 in his chapter on the sick members of the community. Again, Christ is especially present in those who are the most helpless members. It is telling, however, that Benedict admonishes the sick monastics to be considerate of their helpers and not make excessive demands based on their needs, indicating that caregivers make themselves vulnerable and so also come to represent Christ.
Much of what Benedict writes in his code of discipline is painful, but we can be encouraged by Benedict’s encouraging the use of seasoned monks to reason with an excommunicated monastic, offer consolation, and encourage the repentance needed to bring about reconciliation. More important, the abbot is cast into the role of the Good Shepherd who, echoing Jesus’s Parable, itself an echo of Yahweh as the Good Shepherd in Ezekiel 34, leaves the ninety-nine to seek out the one who is lost.
A running thread throughout the Rule is the need for the abbot and the other monastics in the community to provide for the weaker members of the community. Such considerations are needed when considering matters such as allowances for food and drink, and also for assigning work details in the monastery. On a daily basis, all are admonished to be patient with the weaknesses of others, both weaknesses of the body and of the spirit. That is, the presence of Christ in the weaknesses of others is the primary structuring principle of community life.
The threat of “eternal fire” for the goats separated from the sheep in Matthew’s parable is severely jarring when put up against the notion of reaching out to all in need, and even more, when put up against the non-retaliatory teachings of the Sermon on the Mount. I think, however, that we can see this parable as presenting two ways a society can be structured: either a society where all are solicitous of other people, especially the weak, or a society where nobody cares about those who are in need. Surely the latter alternative is hellish, and its horror is not an act of a vengeful god. Indeed, Benedict would have us seek out the lost sheep who have cut themselves off from a society based on identifying the weak with Christ. This is the royal road to the Kingdom of God.

The eighth chapter of Romans is among the most inspirational passages in all scripture. Paul assures us that “all things work together for good for those who love God, who are called according to his purpose” and that we will be “conformed to the image of his Son, in order that he might be the firstborn within a large family.” (Rom. 8: 28–29) Lest we think that only some people are predestined for God’s family, Paul asks: “If God is for us, who is against us?” (Rom. 8: 31) If Jesus is interceding for us, what more powerful persecutor is there to speak against us? Do we really want any personal being to veto the advocacy of Jesus? If we are truly stirred by these words, then we must stamp them deep into our hearts and allow them to govern how we view God and how we view other parts of scripture. For today, I suggest using these words to help us understand the parables in Matthew 13.
Can a charming rogue be an example of how to enter the Kingship of God? Jesus’ Parable of the Dishonest Manager invites us to explore that question.
The rich man who asked Jesus what he needed to do to inherit eternal life and then walked away grieving when Jesus told him to sell all that he owned (Mk. 10: 21) is a warning to all of us, rich or poor. Jesus’ added warning that it “is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for someone who is rich to enter the kingdom of God” only makes the warning all the more dire. Paul strengthens the warning further when he tells Timothy that “the love of money is a root of all kinds of evil,” (1 Tim. 6: 10) Bucking these warnings is our formation from earliest childhood that money is both good and necessary and more of it is always better than less.
There is only one simple qualification for being a disciple of Jesus: give up everything. That’s one whale of a qualification. So hard is this qualification that earnest Christians have thought of many ways to soften Jesus’ words without washing all meaning and challenge out of them. My New Testament professor at Nashotah House, O.C. Edwards, suggested that this qualification means we have to give up everything that comes between us and God. That is, if parents, children, spouses, friends, or fellow members of a community help us draw closer to God, we don’t have to give them up. The same would go for material possessions. Even Benedictine monks have to use things in this world in order to live so we can’t give up having anything at all. The trick is to use things in such a way that the work and recreation we do with them draws us closer to God rather than farther away.


